Built prior to 1900 by Arthur E Marks
Another house built on spec in Fessenden Park.
Directly across William Street from 126 is this once grand Queen Anne. Now a bit forlorn, it’s worthy of our time so let’s stop and get to know it better.
Contemporary to 126, our subject house shows similar stylistic elements. Overall it’s Queen Anne in style and form with some Colonial Revival details. The plan is cruciform with the primary axis running perpendicular to William Street. This axis ends in a powerful gambrelled gable. The placement of the house on a raised lot increases the effect of the gabel’s size.
I’m not quite sure what is going on with that full height projection on the northeast side of the cross gable. It carries the decoration and details of the rest of the house so I believe it to be original. The stacked windows on the upper levels make me think of an extravagant stairway perhaps. Oh to see a floor plan.
The build date is sketchy as the first record for the location I have found is the 1900 Census in which Arthur Marks himself was living there. Marks sold it to Sumner Stanley in May of 1901. Sumner was born in Portland to Rufus and Jane Stanley in 1849. He was the second youngest of 8 children. Rufus was a confectioner who at the time of Sumner’s birth ran a shop in Market Square. By 1880, Rufus was a brewer in Portland and it seems Sumner and his brother Charles followed their father into the field. In 1890 they were both living in Lawrence Massachusetts and were involved with the Suffolk Brewing Company located in South East Boston.
It didn’t last long. Charles Stanley died in 1893. Sumner continued on until his passing in 1906. His will passed our subject to George Fogg who was Sumner’s nephew by his sister Arabella. George was born in 1855. He married Octavia Roach, who was a little less than a year younger, in 1877. George had worked his way up through the ranks at John W Perkins’ wholesale drug business in Portland. By 1910 was a partner and was included in the company’s ad in the city directory for that year.
George and Octavia had 3 sons, George, Charles, and Sumner, who were living with them when they moved into 129 William Street. The Foggs lived there until 1918 when they sold the property to Arthur Chapman and decamped to the Loveitts Field neighborhood in South Portland.
There is some very grand detail work on the house and the fenestration of the street gabel is a prime example. The victorian fan design of the second-story window mullions is especially charming. The tax photo of 1924, below, shows a more developed central window than the current situation. The clamshell arch with adjoining scrollwork above is a bit hard to discern in its current state. The plinth below this feature looks to have been replaced in the last few years and, to my eye, it does not seem quite level. The heavy entablature into which this is set seems overly tall and really adds a lot of weight to the arrangement. The window of the third floor is all colonial revival with a well-scaled Georgian motif in the mullions.
Arthur Chapman was a lawyer and former assistant US attorney when he and Agnes purchased 129 William Street from the Foggs. He was born to Albion and Lizzie Chapman in 1873. His grandfather was the noted historian Leonard Bond Chapman. He graduated from Bowdoin College in 1895 and taught in local schools until he undertook the study of law in 1898. He was admitted to the Maine Bar in 1900.
The dormers are equally impressive in the level of detail they display. They sit in shallow trays and have very fine moldings. They are surrounded by an intricate pilaster and entablature of somewhat Grecian style. The entablature is complete and carries a deep, closed, pediment with vertical (?) siding within. Note also the random ashlar granite of the chimney.
The Chapmans raised 2 sons, Richard and Arthur Jr, at 129 William Street. They remained there until sometime around 1940 when Arthur’s name appears on some documents that state he was a resident of South Portland. He had purchased a lot in Loveitt’s Field in 1938. Chapman had served as a US Commissioner from 1917 to 1925 & was a justice on the Maine Superior Court when he and Agnes sold our subject in 1941. Arthur would serve on the Maine Supreme Court before his death in 1958. Agnes died in 1965.
The dark color around the windows and other places would seem to be the color seen in the tax photo. At some point, the house was resprayed with the lighter color we see now. I have to wonder if they just masked over shutters on the bay window?!
The Chapmans sold the house to Constance Dorfman. Constance grew up on Spruce Street in the West End. She was 20 years old and attending Wellesley College when she purchased our subject. She transferred the house to her mother in 1942 which was the year she graduated and married Daniel Hoffert. Paulene Dorfman sold the home to Eugene and Carolyn Davis in 1950. When they sold it to Paul and Marjorie Berry in 1955, the deed specified
“Also included within are all window shades, venetian blinds, screens, heating and hot water equipment, all carpets attached to floors and stairways and the large mirror over the master bed”
One wonders why the need for such specifics.
Not to be outdone the Berrys included the following codicil in the deed selling the house to David and Ethel Kocher in 1959,
” Also included herewith are all electric light fixtures now in the demised premises, not including, however, any lamps; the wall-to-wall carpeting on the floor in the living room dining room and foyer and the carpeting on the stairs; all screens and screen doors now on the demised premises; all bookshelves built into various locations on the demised premises; and the bar in the cellar.”
The current owners have held the property since 1969.